Friday, 2 May 2008

Do we "Overshare"?


Eh?  Do we what?  Overshare?  What's that then?  Those of us that spend what seems like an increasing part of our days on sites like myLot, Yuwie or the myriad of similar sites have become used to sharing our secrets with each other.  But how far should we go.  The lure of such sites is that they expose us to a far wider variety of thoughts and perspectives than we might otherwise discover from within our own close circle of family and friends.  The anonymity of the internet gives us a sense of security that allows us to reveal intimate details and receive confirmation that we are not so unusual; that ointment X will help that embarrassing spot, that someone else slept with his wife's best friend too etc.

But why do we want to share this information in the first place?  Is it because we are sad, lonely, morbidly curious, exhibitionists, what?  I think that it has something to do with the pseudo psychotherapy approach to modern life, at least in the West.  For years now we have been actively encouraged not to bottle it up, letting go is good.   We are comfortable therefore, with the thought that it is permissible to ask for opinion about almost anything.   We are happy to parade all that ails us in front of our peers.  I belong to a generation that grew up believing that family problems stopped at the garden gate.  You never ever washed your dirty linen in public.  But that approach has now been all but dashed and I, along with thousands of others, seek the comfort and solace that sharing my agony with a strangers brings. I have mentioned elsewhere here that a number of those strangers are no longer viewed in that light by me.  They have become friends, some of them very close.  They know things about me that my family are not necessarily aware of.  I have posed in women's underwear for their amusement.  I would never do that in my local newspaper.   Neither would that be information that I would share with a prospective employer.  But I am happy to share that comedy image with the World!   I feel safe simply because I have placed myself on the global scene rather than the parochial one in which I live.

If we show a willingness to share, then where does the line get drawn?  I am not sure that it does.  I have sat on trains listening to the most personal details of family life as someone finishes his breakfast conversation on the 7.10am to Waterloo (London).  "Darling, I have said I won't see her again. What do you want me to do?  She works in the same building for goodness sake.  Cutting up my suits isn't helpful my love.  You're getting this all out of proportion" and so forth.  Great entertainment, but is it healthy?  We all like a gossip and to know who is doing what and then feign shock and indignation that there should have been such a lowering of morals.  You have to look no further than Oprah, Montel, Jerry Springer to see people happily trotting onto the TV to bare their souls for the delectation of the wider community.  And we love it don't we.  We act as amateur counsellors to the legion of men and women that parade their problems in the hope that somehow we will make it all better.  We receive our 15 minutes of fame too.  Andy Warhol was not so far off the mark then.

Look at the other public things that we do.  To start with, there's this blog.  I have written this for myself but I hope that you will read it too.  Some people put their diaries on-line, others their art and literature.  What about a film, I'll stick it on Youtube.  The possibilities are endless.  Do we feel happier for doing this?  In the old days someone's diary was intensely personal and rarely shared; at least while they were alive.  Now we leap to the internet to share.  We pronounce ourselves happy.  Only time will tell if we really are.

But our happiness to reveal our innermost thoughts comes at a price.  We look for benign, uncritical responses and live in hope of affirmation that what we think, do or believe is acceptable to others.  If their response is less than enthusiastic we sulk, scream or abuse the very people that minutes before we were asking for their help.  But having received this brush off what do we do?  Why, we rush off and ask another question, hopeful that this time the replies will be more generous.  Perhaps we are addicted.  

I don't think that we will return to the days when discretion ruled.  The advent of the internet has brought a freedom that allows us to express ourselves in ways hitherto unthought of.  I can even publish a book myself now abut anything that I want.  No agent, no publisher, just a few words, $20 and I am published.  

So with all that in mind.  I will see you out on the lot.  I've got a very nasty rash somewhere sensitive that I just want to share.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hello p1ke, it's me, nova. I know exactly what you're saying here because I am amazed at the amount of detail I give away about some very personal things when I'm on the Lot, where everything is so very public, but seems so private and confidential, and I don't know why that is. Maybe it IS the distance, the anonymity that the internet provides, I dunno. But I've talked about my own orgasmic ejaculation, what music I like to listen to when I'm making love, my interest in erotica, and so many other personal, detailed, intimate happenings and feelings and desires, mygod, it's really astounding when I think about it. But I like it. And I like the responses I get and the personal details that people share with me about their own lives. And the closeness I've developed with a few people! Wow. You're one of them, you know what I'm talking about. You know things about me that no one but my mother and my husband do and possibly even more. I so treasure the friendships that I've developed on the net, through Mylot. There are three people in particular who have entered my heart, nestled there, and are in for the long haul. You, Spark and Angel. Three IS a magic number, p1ke. But to answer your question, do we overshare? Yeah, probably. But I don't think that's necessarily a bad thing though. Oversharing brought you to me and is keeping you there too. That, I like.

AngelWhispers said...

I do tend to think we over share pike, I mean my husband face has turned green a time or two when he has sat down to read one of our rather delightful discussions. I would never consider sharing some of those things to our offline friends. I men imagine what could happen if you did...

However I do think it is therapeutic, last night I was so overwhelmed with the generosity of mylot and how fast it came together that I was quite emotional, I shared that with Sparks and Mo out in the open and attributed it to the fact it might be pms... Am I embarrassed that I did? hell no I feel quite wonderful today for the exchange. Its all about the connections with the minds and spirits of people you know but don't know.

p1kef1sh said...

Nova my love. What can I say? If the internet didn't exist we would have never met. I dare say that we would have survived but we are so much the better for the benefits that oversharing has brought. Being able to share problems with open minded, but intelligent, thoughtful and caring people has enhanced our lives immeasurably. Being your friend is an honour for me and one that I truly treasure.

Angel. You are so included in that. What you did for your friend last night was truly inspirational, but more than that is showed you as the truly generous person that we know you to be. I'm not sure about the PMS though. However I have shed an inordinate amount of tears this week, got a spare Kleenex?

Unless you are in the sort of friendship that we all have, I think that it is hard to describe. You are quite right, offline friends might struggle indeed to grasp the depth and diversity of the subjects that we discuss. Perhaps it is our oversharing that has brought us together.

Thank you both. XX

Anonymous said...

Very thought provoking p1ke my darling and I think you are right - perhaps we do overshare but I would rather that than go back to the way things used to be! Yes we may get hurt when people are nasty or get down because they think we are wrong but look at the love, support and friendship we receive that totally diminishes the effects to the negative! We probsbly learn more about the heart of our online friends we become closer to and more protective of them , because of the connection we bond which is probably because of the secrets we do share!

I realise I am prattling on and it probably gobbledeegook but I know what I mean and I hope you do too. If it were not for the friends I have met online I do no think I would have gotten through the last year without admission to the psychiatric ward. I
I am thankful for the chance to overshare and for the chance to be there and listen to some of my friends when they do the same and to reciprocate the love, friendship , support and advice that they give to me!

Love you darling fish!
xxxx

p1kef1sh said...

I know exactly what you mean Mummymo and I am delighted that you are one of the people that I have overshared with. We do share some very intimate thoughts, but the fact that we feel able to do so is testament to the support that we receive from our audience. Personally, I am the luckiest man alive. Not only do I have the love and friendship from my family, but from so many others too.

I love you too Mummymo, and missing you beyond belief. XX

Anonymous said...

Hi p1ke, You just have a way of saying things, yes the guy on the train is a bit much and we all do tend to overshare a bit, me more so in PM's than on posts even though I have asked for advice over some things, most recently the fact that my sons father is picking him up and putting him down as and when it suits and I feel that is unhealthy and could affect my son as he is now getting older. I received so much good advice on that one that if shared with friends they would have been biased whereas on myLot they are sharing without knowing both parties indepth which I think is great. Nice to see you are now popping back in now and then too. Have a beautiful day. Ellie :D